Guide

How to tell if a tree needs to come down

Most trees that fail give warning first. Here is what to actually look for before you decide.

4 August 2026 · 2 min read

A tree rarely fails without warning. The warning is just easy to miss if you do not know what you are looking at, and most of it is visible from the ground.

Fungal brackets and conks

A shelf-like fungal growth on the trunk or at the base is not cosmetic. It means the wood inside is decaying, and the size of the tree tells you nothing about how much sound wood is left holding it up. A large tree with a compromised root plate or trunk base can fail with very little wind.

Cracks, cavities and included bark

A vertical crack in the trunk, a cavity you can see into, or a narrow, bark-lined seam where two large limbs meet (included bark) are all structural weak points. None of them heal. They only get more loaded as the tree keeps growing around them.

Root plate movement

Soil lifting or cracking on one side of the trunk, especially after wind, means the root plate has already started to move. This is one of the more urgent signs: a tree in this state can go over in the next strong blow, not the next storm season.

Deadwood in the canopy

Dead branches at height are a falling-limb risk long before the tree itself is at risk, and they are the easiest sign to check yourself: stand back and look for bare, brittle wood against the live canopy, particularly after a dry summer.

What to actually do with this list

One sign on its own is often manageable with pruning rather than felling. Two or more together, especially root movement plus anything structural in the trunk, is when it is worth getting someone to look at it properly rather than waiting for the next inspection window. Where it lands if it does go is the harder question, and it is usually the one that decides whether a tree comes down whole or in sections.

Questions worth asking first

Does a leaning tree always need to come down?
No. Some species and some trees have leaned the same way for decades and are stable. What matters is whether the lean is new, whether the soil on the high side has lifted or cracked, and whether the root plate is moving. A lean that has been checked and photographed once is worth checking again after the next big storm, not assumed to be fine forever.
Can a tree be saved instead of felled?
Often, yes. Crown reduction, cabling, or removing a single failed limb can extend a tree's safe life by years. Felling is the option for a tree where the risk cannot be reduced enough by working on it in place, not the default first move.

Related service

Tree felling

Safe removals done by experienced fellers using relevant roping techniques. For more complex removals we have access to a crane truck with an experienced operator.

More on tree felling

More guides

Worth reading next.

Tell us what the job is.

  • Fully insured
  • Across the Cape Peninsula

A tree that has to come down, a stump in the way of a new lawn, a load of firewood before winter, the chipper for a weekend, or a garden kept on a schedule. Send us the suburb and what you need.

We come out and look at it properly.